The Message, October 25, 2026: "The Good Life," Matthew 22:34-46
Author: Rev. Scott W. Cousineau
October 29, 2026
“The Good Life”
A Message by Rev. Scott W. Cousineau
Matthew 22:34-46
As I contemplated the message this
week, a thought … or a question … occurred to me. Is it possible to preach on
the Greatest Commandment too often?
Is there a chance that it can become
one of those lessons that you hear so often that you begin to tune it out?
“Okay … here we go: ‘Love the Lord,
your God, with all your heart and all your soul and all your strength … la
... la … la … la … la … la … la. We got it. Love your neighbor as
yourself.’ Thanks, Pastor Scott. Good message. Can we go to coffee hour now?”
Nope. Sorry. Let us see how much you really missed me last Sunday. Besides … the Church School teachers need
time to finish their lesson for the week.
So, let us see what is happening
here.
In Mark’s Gospel, the question that
was put to Jesus came from a ‘friendly scribe.’ However, in Matthew’s account,
there is no sign of that friendly scribe. Instead, the question is asked by an
Unfriendly Pharisee. The reality is that Matthew’s community painted most of
the Jewish teachers with an unfriendly brush.
In Matthew’s account, those
unfriendly Pharisees sought to challenge Jesus. They wanted to trip him up so
that they might have more concrete evidence against him. “When the Pharisees
heard that he had silenced the Sadducees, they gathered together, and one of
them, an expert in the law, asked him a question to test him. ‘Teacher, which
commandment in the law is the greatest?’”
There
was a common view in Jewish thinking that all of the commandments were of equal
importance in God’s eyes. Therefore, it would be sinful to single out one as
being more important than the others. Clearly, they were thinking, “Let us ask
him a question that is impossible to answer.”
And
yet, Jesus did answer. His answer was so traditional … so foundational … so in
keeping with their faith … that it was hard to challenge him.
Yes,
we are traversing familiar territory here, but in his response, Jesus cited
Deuteronomy 6:5, a passage known as the Shema … the Sh’ma: “Hear,
O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one. You shall love the Lord your God
with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. This is the
first and the greatest commandment.”
Jesus
did indeed sift through the six hundred and thirteen commandments in the Law of
Moses and identified Deuteronomy 6:5 as the first and the greatest. Because
this commandment was more than a “Do this” or “Do not do that” commandment or
law. Those words were the most frequently spoken words in all of scripture.
Those words were the prayer that began each worship service. That prayer was
the prayer that every faithful Jew spoke every single day of their lives.
He
then combined Deuteronomy 6:5 with Leviticus 19:18: “And a second is like it,
‘You shall love your neighbor as yourselves.’ On these two commandments hang
all of the law and the prophets.”
If we were to climb into our
Biblical time machines and set the date for the beginning of Jesus’ ministry,
we would find ourselves on a mountainside. When Jesus saw the crowds, he
climbed the mount and began to teach. He began by offering the Beatitudes. He
went into his teaching on salt and light. And then he said these words: “Do
not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have come not
to abolish but to fulfill.” (Matthew 5:17) And then he used the remainder
of the Sermon on the Mount to establish just how it was that Jesus and his
teaching fulfilled the Law and the Prophets.
Jesus was not the first to combine
the two passages of scripture. The Testament of the Twelve Patriarchs frequently
referred to loving the Lord and loving the neighbor. But in his response, Jesus
elevated those two commandments. They are the two upon which everything else is
built.
If we climb out of our Biblical time
machines, let us now consider what this means for us today two thousand years
later. In a day and age in which the word “love” is often over-used, misused, and
even abused, we should remember that the primary component of biblical ‘love’
was not about affection or warm feelings. Rather, the word meant ‘commitment.’
Warm feelings of gratitude or affection may be associated with the way that we
feel about God and all that God has done for us, but Deuteronomy 6:5 does not
command us to have warm feelings for God. It does command us to have a total
and unwavering commitment to God with all that we are.
Likewise, “loving” our neighbors …
including our enemies as Jesus will add later … does not mean having affection
or warm feelings for them. To “love” our neighbor means to imitate God and to
possess genuine concern for them and their needs and their well-being.
Loving God and loving neighbor is
more than a “To Do” list of which we can check off items as we accomplish
certain ‘required’ tasks. Jesus invites us into a new way, a new life with
total commitment to God as the foundation. Jesus invites us to see the world
through different eyes. He invites us into relationship with the world with a
different heart and spirit.
When Jesus’ cousin, John the Baptist,
come onto the scene, he invited the people to step into the waters of baptism.
His baptism was one of repentance. Turn away from the things, the ways, of this
world and turn toward God. Turn away from worldly passions and hungers and turn
toward God. Jesus came and invited us into a new baptism, a baptism of fire.
Jesus baptized with the fire of the Spirit.
As I have said, this message has not
introduced anything that you have not heard before. This is all familiar
territory. But how many of us learn a lesson and follow that lesson after
hearing it just once? How many times did our parents or guardians tell us to
play nice? Or share our toys? How many times did we hear, ‘drive safe,’ or ‘if
you do not have anything nice to say, don’t say anything at all’?
Even the most faithful among us,
even those who had received perfect attendance award in Sunday school, and
those who attend worship every Sunday can at times struggle with the renewing
of our hearts and minds and souls. No matter how many times we hear the words
and the teachings of Jesus there can be bits of darkness or impurity or
judgement that linger and lurk in the nooks and crannies of our hearts and
souls. It can … and typically does … require very intentional work and effort
on our part to expose those nooks and crannies to the light and love of God.
We hear the words of Jesus, we hear
his teaching, and we know how we are SUPPOSED to feel.
We hear Jesus’ words and we know the
“love” that we all agree should be there …
We hear the words and we know what
Jesus asks of us …
But sometimes it does not come
easily or swiftly. There may be some of us who were baptized in the Spirit and
“whoosh!” our hearts and souls are as pure as the driven snow. But I think that
many of us have found that our journey into this new way and new life comes in
steps.
These two commandments lifted up by
Jesus as first and greatest are not orders that are meant to be obeyed
according to our own strength and will. Instead, they are offered as
invitations to engage in a new way of life by the ongoing renewal of our spirits.
A new life in which, bit by bit … step by step, pride and selfishness, prejudice
and hatred can be replaced by love and grace and mercy and genuine concern for
the well-being of our neighbors.
Jesus addressed and reinforced this
new way of being in relationship with God and with one another in the question
that he asked of the Pharisees. According to the centuries old hope and prayer
of the Jewish people, the messiah as understood to the ‘Son of David’
meant the coming king who would win military battles over Israel’s enemies.
That warrior messiah would set the people free from occupation and oppression.
However, that notion of the warrior
messiah could hardly encourage people to love God with all of their hearts,
minds, souls and strength and then also to love their neighbors as themselves.
How does the warrior messiah encourage one to love those whom you hope and pray
that he will defeat and destroy? After all … back into our time machine … in
that Sermon on the Mount, Jesus reminded the people on that hillside that God
is the Creator and Lover of the whole world, not just a chosen segment of it.
Jesus tells us, and then shows us,
that the Messiah is MORE THAN the Son of David. The Messiah is MORE THAN a king
or a prince from the House and Line of David. The Messiah is MORE THAN an
earthly conqueror. Jesus taught, then
demonstrates, that the Messiah is the Son of God that will defeat the true
threat to humanity.
Every time that I left my parents’
house to drive home, my mother would say to me, “Drive safe. Don’t speed.” And
every time I got in the car … I exceeded the speed limit. (Unless someone was
tailgating me … then I drove the speed limit on the dot.)
We need to hear these lessons over
and over again. “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and
with all your soul and with all your mind. This is the greatest and first
commandment. And a second is like it: You shall love your neighbor as yourself.
On these two commandments hang all the Law and the Prophets.”
We need to let them work on our
hearts.
We need to let them chip away at the
darkness that still lurks and lingers.
We need to commit ourselves
completely and faithfully to living in this way.
May these words be our daily prayer.
May we live like trees planted by
streams of living water and may we bear fruit … abundantly.
Amen and amen.
BACK